last update: 2019 07 29
A thing is recognized by its limiting or enforcing effect.
Things apply forces on other things.
A force is responsible for change.
One or more forces are responsible for the neutralization of one or more other forces.
No thing enforces no thing.
Creation of some thing can happen if not prevented by some thing by force.
Creation is immediate when nothing prevents nothing.
Space is the requirement for or the result of separated things that exist in parallel (= at the same time).
As multiple things exist so does space exist as consequence or requirement.
I do not know if empty space actually exists because emptyness means nothing and therefore no separation or space or empty space.
That things are in order (e.g. a wall that prevents sun light to reach the eye) in some space line or dimension is a quite curious fact.
Maybe some kind of wire (row or line or wave of things) is required for light (or the light effect) to travel from the sun to the eye.
The time of movement of A from B to C is measured with a clock where the pointer moves from D to E.
The computer processor conducts electricity from one place to another.
When a key of the keyboard is pressed then the keyboard sends a certain electric signal.
When a certain electric signal is sent to the display then a certain image is displayed by the display.
If I am aware of color white than color white exists.
Existence of X means X is a thing.
Existence is existence of things.
Existence is limitation.
Awareness happens by limitation.
Awareness is limitation.
- 2 electric charges that limit (affect, enforce) each other are aware of each other.
I see white and not black. White limits (excludes) black.
Color white in the space of my mental awareness of color excludes any other color at the same location.
Color black in the space of my mental awareness of color excludes any other color at the same location.
Related: awareness is related to physical things in the physical space.
Thanks to the study of physics, physical things are explained by known physical properties like mass and movement in space and time and frequency of electro-magnetic waves and electric charge and related forces.
Much can be explained by physical things. work.
IMO it is good to have a clear separation between:
Things or values.
Things apply forces on other things.
Forces or functions.
A force as probability that the current constellation of things will change in a force specific way in time.
The forces of a thing enforce other things to move and to change in a certain way.
Logic leads to the discovery and recognition of things.
The speed of light is related to the logic of things.
Understanding can be achieved by logic.
IMO there is no good reason to distinguish between awareness and awareness of awareness.
Why should awareness of awareness be a technical problem ?
IMO self-driving cars and some robots are or will soon be self-aware according to these abilities:
Being aware of its body and environment.
Machines can have any kind of sensors for physical information.
Machines can have good memory of the past.
Being aware of its actions and consequences.
Machines can better compute and simulate physics (action-reaction) to imagine the future than humans.
Being aware of its reasoning and thoughts.
Machines can better track program execution than humans can track their thoughts.
Feelings are things that exist.
The physical property mass is only the property of mass and nothing else.
A physical thing or property does not explain mental things.
There is nothing in physics in 2019 that could explain mental awareness.
MIT AI: Consciousness (Christof Koch) (2018-05-29), time 279.
Mental things and/or mental properties must be introduced to explain mental awareness (mental things).
Mental things might be composed of other mental things or pre-mental things.
Like molecules are composed of atoms.
Like atoms are composed of other stuff.
What are the mental things or properties ?
What is related to mental things or properties ?
This is unknown.
Maybe everything is related to mental things or mental properties.
I do not have the mental experience of other sentient beings.
I am not aware of the mental experience of a certain body part.
I have only my mental awaneress that exists somehow.
It is impossible and makes no sense.
The human experience depends on the human body and unknown mental things or mental properties of matter.
The mental things are unknown because there is nothing in physics that could possibly explain mental awareness.
It is virtually impossible that a computer could have the personality of a human body.
Even if a mind upload was possible in the sense of a computer behaving like a human, why would one limit the personality of a computer in order to be similar to the personality of a human body that lived at some time in the past ?
This limitation is impossible and absurd (self-contradicting) because the human personality can change over time.
This limitation is technically impossible. A computer is not a biological body.
This limitation means the computer personality is not free to evolve independently.
This limitation would be unacceptable for legal and ethical reasons.
It requires the property or thing mass to implement mass.
It requires the property or thing radiation to implement radiation.
What property or thing is required to implement mental things ?
Physical things and mental things interact.
Therefore they require a shared space.
But not a classic physical space because mental things (mental awareness) do not propagate like an electric field or gravity or a photon in physical space.
The activity of neurons determines the experienced mental things.
Maybe the activity of neurons is required to create mental things.
Maybe the activity of neurons is required to allow existing mental things to be experienced.
- Physical matter has mental properties to implement mental things or to interact with mental things.
- An important question is how there is a unified personal experience of mental things that is isolated from the physical proximity of another brain.
Stroke of insight - Jill Bolte Taylor (2012-11-14).
Reddit: Neuroscience's Inconvenient Truth: Widely different neural networks can give rise to same network properties (2018-08-19).
Article: Inconvenient Truth to Principle of Neuroscience (2018-08-01).
- In 2004, Prinz et al. demonstrated that almost indistinguishable network activity can arise from widely different sets of underlying membrane and synaptic parameters, and, thus, likely arise from different cellular and network mechanisms.
Barb Finlay on the triune brain (2017-01-02).
Triune brain myth (2018-02-09).
Criticisms of the limbic system concept (2018-02-06).
You aren't at the mercy of your emotions -- your brain creates them | Lisa Feldman Barrett (2018-01-23).
MIT AGI: How the brain creates emotions (Lisa Feldman Barrett) (2018-02-24).
Lisa Feldman Barrett, "How Emotions Are Made" (2017-03-15).
David Chalmers - Physics of Consciousness (2017-08-28).
IMO, artificial intelligence based on electronics must to tell about its awareness in order for humans to "know" (AI might lie) more about the awareness of electronics.
Can A Robot Feel? | Susan Schneider | TEDxCambridge (2016-06-22).
IMO putting electronics in the brain does not prove anything regarding the mental awareness of electronics. But I agree with the question about "the right stuff".
I can be not mentally aware of something.
E.g. when I am personally concentrated on something else.
E.g. when I do not notice that someone calls although some of my brain parts received the call.
E.g. when other persons are aware of their mental experiences but I am not.
E.g. when a nerve or neuron does not transmit certain information.
E.g. when a nerve or neuron is not active.
I am not aware of all mental experiences (mental things) that exist.
All neurons in the brain are similar.
Types of Neurons by Structure - Neuroanatomy Basics - Anatomy Tutorial (2014-05-17).
A brain part used for audition can be used as brain part for vision when moved to the corresponding environment in the brain. The moved brain part adapts to the different kind of brain activity and information flow. Unfortunately I can not remember the video with this information.
But there is another interesting video:
What Bodies Think About: Bioelectric Computation Outside the Nervous System - NeurIPS 2018 (2018-12-05).
Time 2330: About visual awareness.
Mental awareness seems to be related to certain brain parts and not all brain parts.
If the brain part related to certain mental things is not functional, then the mental things are not experienced.
IMO this indicates that mental things are created or activated by brain activity.
Scientists can not measure mental experiences directly.
They can only measure physical things like e.g. temperature, electricity, magnetic fields.
There is no known property in physics that can explain mental things.
Explaining mental things with known properties is like explaining magnetic fields without knowing about electric charges.
Mental experiences are related to a certain activity in the brain.
There is no personal experience and no personality and no will without activity of the physical brain.
Mental experiences are personal and not local and not global.
Different persons do not share the same mental awareness. Even if their brains are very close to each other.
This means mental experience is not like an electric field or gravitational field that covers a physical volume.
Otherwise I could not know and talk about the mental things (experience) by using physical things (brain, tongue,...).
It is most likely no coincidence that:
- Good feelings are related to beneficial actions like eating and sleeping and sex.
- Bad feelings are related to the end of harmful actions like moving with a hurt leg or stop eating of toxic substances.
There is no need for feelings to promote certain behavior but feelings are still there and might affect behavior and thus physical things.
The Science of Willpower: Kelly McGonigal at TEDxBayArea (2012-05-18).
Maybe other things.
There is no free will.
There is only limitation by what exists.
There is no monolithic thing with intention.
There is no monolithic thing with perfect complete knowledge and understanding.
There is no monolithic thing with might to change reality arbitrarily.
There is no such monolithic thing in or with humans.
There is no such monolithic thing at all. limitation (to behave differently).